Could you run this pub in Pickering?

The Bay Horse, a stunning Grade II-listed pub nestled in the bustling centre of Pickering, is seeking a passionate and talented publican to lead it into its next chapter.

Pub and location

Set within a charming terrace building, The Bay Horse is a pub steeped in history and character.

Its original Tudor beams, crackling open fire, and the evocative Cromwell Room, complete with a centuries-old priest hole, create an atmosphere that captivates guests from the moment they step inside.

This timeless appeal draws in both locals and visitors, especially those exploring the North York Moors or arriving via the iconic Pickering to Whitby steam railway, making it a natural haven for rest and refreshment.

Beyond its historic interior, the pub offers a spacious back beer garden, a peaceful spot perfect for alfresco dining or a quiet drink in the open air. Inside, guests can unwind in the traditional front tap room, relax in the cosy rear lounge with its mezzanine level, or host intimate gatherings in the versatile private function room designed for meetings or private dining.

Located on the busy A170 between Thirsk and Scarborough, The Bay Horse enjoys excellent visibility and a steady stream of foot traffic, making it an ideal destination for both spontaneous drop-ins and planned visits.

The Bay Horse is more than a pub; it’s a destination, a community hub, and a piece of living history. If you’re ready to take ownership of a venue with soul, style, and endless potential, we’d love to hear from you.

Proposed Investment

There is also a planned refurbishment upon approval for the rear trading areas, beer garden & external decorations.

Ideal Publican

This is a standout opportunity for a passionate hospitality professional, or an experienced couple, with a solid foundation in food service and a history of delivering excellence.

The right candidate will be someone who consistently upholds high standards, thrives under the pressure of a bustling summer season, and understands the importance of forging strong connections with the local community.

Success in this role will come from blending creativity and leadership with genuine warmth, ensuring every pint poured and every plate served reflects the heart and soul of the pub.

Private accommodation

This exciting opportunity comes with two bedrooms, a lounge and a kitchen.

About the Agreement

We love working with experienced entrepreneurs and we’re happy to be flexible with our agreements and products to match your business and vision.

Our Flexible Tenancy agreement offers a piece of mind approach to running your own pub business for a total term of up to 5-years with a flexible notice period. We offer flexible deposit options, as well as flexible price bands and release fees which are available.

Whatever the agreement, with Punch you always get:

A progressive pub company – winners of the Publican Awards 2022 & 2024!

• Industry leading investment with a whole world of possibilities
• Industry leading training, with our Academy and Kitchen
• Industry leading e-commerce platform – Punch Buying Club
• Expert coaching and advice every step of the way

Chat to a recruitment advisor now about this pub business opportunity.