A Well‑Known Village Dining Pub Close to Scotch Corner
Pub Overview
The Shoulder of Mutton is a well-loved village pub in Middleton Tyas, set within a 400‑year‑old building full of character. It has long been part of local village life and is known for offering a warm welcome, good hospitality and a strong reputation for food. The menu focuses on well‑made, locally sourced dishes, including its popular steak and ale pie, seasonal specials and Sunday roasts.
With around 50 covers, a fully equipped catering kitchen and a private function room seating up to 16 guests, the pub offers fantastic flexibility for dining, business meetings and small gatherings. The bar serves a choice of well-kept drinks including cask ales, lagers, spirits and wines, making it a go‑to spot for both locals and destination diners.
Pub & Location
Inside, the pub has several cosy rooms and smaller spaces, each with its own character. Guests can enjoy relaxed drinks or a sit‑down meal, with a central bar that brings everything together. The beamed ceilings, traditional décor and intimate corners create a warm and welcoming feel.
Outside, there is a gazebo at the front which provides extra space for drinking and dining, as well as a smoking solution to the rear. The pub also benefits from a large car park with around 20 spaces, making it easy for visitors and travellers to stop by.
Middleton Tyas is just a minute from Scotch Corner, giving the pub excellent access to the A1 and A66. This location helps create steady customer flow from commuters, tourists, and people travelling across North Yorkshire, as well as strong support from the village and surrounding communities. The pub is also well placed for those visiting Richmond, the Yorkshire Dales and other local attractions.
Ideal Publican
This opportunity would suit someone confident running a pub where food plays an important role. The ideal operator will enjoy offering good quality, locally sourced dishes and creating a warm, consistent experience for guests. Local knowledge would be useful but isn’t essential. Most importantly, the operator should feel comfortable building relationships within the village while also welcoming people from the surrounding towns and further afield.
Accommodation
The private accommodation consists of three bedrooms, a kitchen and a lounge.
About the Agreement
At Punch, we support talented, ambitious entrepreneurs who want to run brilliant pubs at the heart of their communities. That’s why our agreements are designed to be flexible, supportive and built around your vision.
Our Flexible Tenancy gives you the freedom to run your own pub with confidence. A tied agreement of up to five years, where you’ll benefit from the drink products available to Punch which also offers flexible notice periods. We offer flexible deposits, tie‑release options, and pricing structures to help you shape your business in a way that works for you.
Why Choose Punch?
When you partner with Punch, you’ll have an entire support system behind you, including:
- A forward thinking pub company, recognised nationally with multiple industry awards including winners of the Publican Awards 2022 & 2024!
- Potential investment to unlock your pub’s full potential
- Industry leading training through our award winning Academy, complete with state of the art kitchens, bars and our immersive Progress with Punch training programme.
- Access to our powerful online platform, the Punch Buying Club, where you can order stock and find resources to help you run your pub successfully.
- Ongoing coaching from expert Operations Managers and specialist support teams.
- Innovative digital learning through THIRST, our gamified online training app, offering compliance training through to driving sales training.
Chat to a recruitment advisor now about this pub business opportunity.
Oak Tree Inn 
Golden Lion 
Kings Head 
Golden Lion 
Smiths Arms